I’ve made no secret that I’m only average or mediocre in the personal-finance skill of frugality. But I like to think I at least pay attention to price and to getting value for what I pay. When I buy things—especially big-ticket purchases—I often do research, shop around, and negotiate. Heck, when I’m at an all-you-can-eat buffet, I tend to go in with a hearty appetite and even target those food items I believe to be more expensive.
But I’m paying less attention than I thought.
I’m not someone who buys a latte every morning, but sometimes the urge will strike me. At that point, sometimes the spirit of frugality takes hold, and I think to myself that I don’t really need an expensive coffee drink, and I keep walking. And other times, I think, it’s not so bad, and not so expensive, and I don’t get them that often. And into Starbuck’s (or wherever) I go.
Then I pretty much get whatever I want. The prices of the drinks aren’t that different. There’s no second round of frugality or thriftiness pushing me toward saving a quarter or fifty cents through my choice of beverage.
I had no idea I was being a sucker.
A sucker in this sense. Once I’m in the coffee shop, I’ve already decided to make an impulse purchase—and unlike when I’m making a deliberate purchase for which I’ve considered price and value, I am essentially paying no attention to price or value.
Which costs more for a coffee shop to make—a cappuccino, a mocha, or a white-chocolate mocha? I had no idea and wasn’t stopping to think about it for one moment. In turn, I had no idea if the prices I’m being charged are matching up with the coffee shop’s costs.
Tim Harford’s book, The Undercover Economist, peeled back the curtain, using the examples of a hot chocolate, a cappuccino, a mocha, a white-chocolate mocha, and a 20-oz. cappuccino at Starbucks:
Every single product on the menu above costs Starbuck’s almost the same to produce, down to the odd nickel or two…
Despite the costs being the same, Harford gives the wide range of the prices for these five products from his local Starbucks in Washington, DC (presumably circa 2005, when the book was published): $2.20 for a hot chocolate; $2.55 for a cappuccino; $2.75 for a mocha; $3.20 for a white-chocolate mocha; and $3.40 for a 20-oz. cappuccino. Harford brings the point home by noting that the mocha is just the hot chocolate and cappuccino mixed together and the white-chocolate mocha is the same as the mocha except for use of a different powder.
So while I was blowing off the difference of about fifty cents in ordering a white-chocolate mocha, I was actually paying at least 23% more for the same drink as a mocha—or arguably 54% more for a glorified hot chocolate.
Harford explains that I’m essentially Starbuck’s most-desired customer:
By charging wildly different prices for products that have largely the same cost, Starbuck’s is able to smoke out customers who are less sensitive about the price. Starbucks doesn’t have a way to identify lavish customers perfectly, so it invites them to hang themselves with a choice of luxurious ropes.
By the way, Harford does not paint Starbuck’s as evil, from my read—and in fact, far from it, he points out many other businesses do something quite similar and discusses many such practices by supermarkets.
But the imagery of hanging myself with a luxurious rope will stick with me, I think. Is it frugal, cheap, or something else if I order the cappuccino and hot chocolate and mix them together myself?
Better yet, next time I see the coffee shop, I’ll just keep on walking.
Related Posts:
What an interesting article. I do the same as you when I am buying chocolate - I only glance at the prices to make sure they are not outrageous but generally buy the bar that looks the best and take no notice of the price at all.
To keep the math simple, let's say coffee is about $2/lb. A pot is 2oz, so 25 cents. I get 4 big cups out of that pot. The first cup goes with me in the car, the rest in the fridge. The next three days I pour a cup and use the microwave. 6-1/4 cents a cup, give or take. When the missus buys her $4 coffee, I do the math in my head, I get about 2 months of coffee for that one drink she gets. I don't point that out because I am happily married. Wait, I mean I am happily married because I don't point that out.
I buy the lattes when I am on business travel and my company is buying me my meals.
Joe
Thanks for the comments!
Joetaxpayer,
Thanks for doing the math on that -- I hadn't tried that particular comparison. But I am glad to hear you are happily married -- and keeping it that way by not pointing that math out! Now despite the difference on caffeine beverages, are you otherwise getting along well in your respective approaches to saving money?
Keep an open mind at the coffee shop. I occasionally get a coffee drink at my local coffee shop. I get a mocha with an extra shot of espresso. Their sign advertises a drink called a quad latte. One day I decided to ask what it was, and it turns out it is just what I order, only without the chocolate. I found out I can order this drink, and have them add chocolate (at no charge!), and have the same drink at a lower price.
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow or
wow po
cheap wow gold
toms outlet
beats by dre
cheap nba jerseys
rolex watches
louis vuitton bags
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet online
nike tn pas cher
ferragamo shoes
longchamp outlet
camisetas futbol baratas
nike tn pas cher
true religion jeans outlet
burberry outlet store
fitflops outlet
coach outlet store
tiffany and co
christian louboutin outlet
hollister uk
ralph lauren polo
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren outlet
louis vuitton pas cher
mcm backpack
toms outlet
links of london jewellery
true religion jeans
true religion canada
true religion jeans
true religion uk outlet
coach outlet online
michael kors wallet
jianbin0712
nike huarache
mulberry handbags
hollister
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet online
replica watches
lacoste shirts
longchamp pliage
soccer jerseys
tiffany outlet
longchamp handbags
bottega veneta outlet online
chrome hearts
christian louboutin uk
instyler ionic styler
longchamp outlet
air max 90
michael kors wallet sale
ferragamo outlet
nike air max 90
rolex watches outlet
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet online
burberry outlet
cheap jordan shoes
nike air max uk
coach outlet
toms outlet
beats by dre
cheap nba jerseys
rolex watches
louis vuitton bags
jianbin0712
nike huarache
mulberry handbags
hollister
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet online
replica watches
lacoste shirts
longchamp pliage
soccer jerseys
tiffany outlet
longchamp handbags
bottega veneta outlet online
chrome hearts
christian louboutin uk
instyler ionic styler
longchamp outlet
air max 90
michael kors wallet sale
ferragamo outlet
nike air max 90
rolex watches outlet
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet online
burberry outlet
cheap jordan shoes
nike air max uk
coach outlet
toms outlet
beats by dre
cheap nba jerseys
rolex watches
louis vuitton bags
cheap jordans
ray ban sunglasses
coach factory outlet
coach outlet
coach factory outlet
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton
gucci outlet
adidas shoes
jordan 13
michael kors handbags
gucci outlet
louis vuitton outlet
basketball shoes
michael kors outlet
jordan retro 11
canada goose jackets
michael kors outlet
air jordans
michael kors handbags
prada outlet
true religion outlet
uggs outlet
rolex watches outlet
coach outlet
kate spade outlet
mont blanc fountain pens
coach outlet
rolex watches
chenyingying20160906
coach factory outlet
longchamp handbags
adidas yeezy
hollister jeans
pandora charms
christian louboutin sale
stivali ugg
broncos jerseys
hollister outlet
true religion
2017.1.4xukaimin
christian louboutin
rolex watches
adidas yeezy
pandora outlet
fendi handbags
michael kors purses
tommy hilfiger
christian louboutin shoes
sac longchamp pas cher
abercrombie and fitch
20170222caiyan
cheap jerseys wholesale
coach outlet
mulberry handbags sale
cleveland cavaliers jerseys
reebok shoes
nhl jerseys wholesale
nike outlet online
louis vuitton outlet stores
michael kors uk
louis vuitton outlet online
qqqqqing20170520